Having a website is the first step. What really matters is understanding how it performs: who visits it, where they come from and what they do once they’re there. Without that data, every decision about the site is a gamble.
Google Analytics 4 (GA4) and Google Search Console are the two free tools for measuring it. The problem is that most guides just list metrics. In this article we look at which ones to watch, how to read them and what to do with what they tell you.
GA4 and Search Console: what each one measures
The simplest way to understand them is to think about a visit’s journey:
| Search Console | Google Analytics 4 | |
|---|---|---|
| What it measures | What happens on Google, before the click | What happens on your website, after the click |
| Questions it answers | Do I appear? For which searches? In which position? | Who arrives? What do they do? Do they complete the action? |
| Traffic source | Google organic search only | Every channel: organic, social, email, direct, ads |
| Key data | Impressions, clicks, CTR, position, indexing | Users, engagement, key events, revenue |
Google Analytics 4: the metrics that matter
GA4 isn’t organised around sessions and page views like its predecessor, but around events: every interaction is an event. That makes it very flexible, but also easy to get lost in. These are the metrics worth following.
1. Active users
This is the number of people who interacted with your site in the period. It’s the user metric GA4 shows by default in its reports, and you’ll find it in the Acquisition section.
How to read it:
- If it grows month on month, your acquisition channels are working.
- If it stays flat but key events go up, you’re attracting traffic that’s a better fit for what you offer.
- If it drops, check which channel fell and whether it’s a seasonal effect.
Always compare equivalent periods: this month against last month, or against the same month last year if your sector is seasonal.
2. Engagement rate
This is the percentage of engaged sessions. GA4 counts a session as engaged if it lasted longer than 10 seconds, included a key event or had at least 2 page views. Bounce rate still exists in GA4, but it’s now simply the opposite: the percentage of sessions that weren’t engaged.
There’s no universal “good” percentage. A page that answers a question in one paragraph may have a low rate and still be doing its job. What’s useful is comparing against your own history and by type of page. If a page that used to perform suddenly drops, check its loading speed, whether the content still answers what people are looking for, and which channel that traffic comes from.
The reverse is also true: high engagement isn’t always a good sign. If someone browses ten pages and doesn’t complete any action, they may not be finding what they need.
3. Key events
In GA4 everything is an event, but some matter more: the ones that represent a result for your business, such as a form submission, a purchase or a click to WhatsApp. Google calls them key events; they used to be called conversions.
How to read them:
- Don’t just look at the total. Look at the rate: how many sessions end in a key event.
- Split by channel. Which source brings the people who then get in touch: organic search, social, email, direct traffic?
- Look at the journey. Many people don’t contact you on their first visit. GA4’s attribution reports show which channels play a part beforehand.
Without key events set up, GA4 is just a visit counter. Define at least the two or three that matter most to your business.
4. Revenue and purchase behaviour (for online stores)
If you run an online store with ecommerce tracking set up, GA4 shows in the Monetisation section:
- Total revenue, the gross figure. It matters, but it isn’t enough.
- Average revenue per user, to know how much each visitor is worth on average.
- Best-selling items, to know what drives your sales.
- The purchase funnel: how many people add to cart, start checkout and finish buying. If many start checkout and few buy, there’s friction in the checkout. In the most common checkout mistakes we go over where the problem usually is.
Search Console: visibility and performance on Google
While GA4 tells you what people do on your website, Search Console shows how Google sees you and which searches you appear for. It’s the foundation tool for measuring your SEO.
1. Impressions, clicks and CTR
These are the metrics in the Performance report:
- Impressions: how many times your page appeared in the results.
- Clicks: how many times people clicked on your result.
- CTR: clicks divided by impressions. It shows how appealing your result is: title, description and URL.
Two signals to watch:
- Lots of impressions and few clicks. The page appears but doesn’t persuade. Review the title and meta description. It can also happen that the answer is already visible on Google, for example in an AI summary; we cover this in how AI Overviews and AI Mode affect traffic.
- Few impressions. The page isn’t appearing for relevant searches or has indexing problems.
2. Average position
This is the average position your page appears in for the searches where it was shown. Since it’s an average across many different searches, it’s best read by query and by page, not just as an overall number.
How to read it:
- Positions 1 to 3: the area that takes most of the clicks.
- Positions 4 to 10: page one, but with limited visibility.
- Positions 11 to 20: page two. Very few people get that far.
The quickest opportunity is usually in pages between positions 4 and 20: Google already considers them relevant, and with better content, internal links and an update they can move up.
3. Queries
This report shows which searches you appear for and which ones bring you clicks. Use it to:
- Discover searches you appear for without having worked on them.
- Spot topics without their own page. If you appear for a search but don’t have content dedicated to that topic, it’s a sign to create it.
- Find longer, more specific variations you can add to the content you already have.
If you want to go beyond what already shows up in Search Console, in how to choose keywords we explain the full method.
4. Page indexing
It isn’t a traffic metric, but it’s critical: if Google doesn’t index a page, that page can’t appear. The report is under Indexing > Pages and splits pages into indexed and not indexed, with the reason for each one.
What to check:
- That your important pages are indexed. Services, products, main articles.
- The real errors. A server error (5xx) or a 404 on a page that should exist needs fixing. A 404 on a page you deleted on purpose is normal.
- The exclusion reasons. Many exclusions are correct, such as pages with
noindexon purpose, redirects or duplicate versions with their canonical. What you’re looking for is important pages excluded by mistake.
The same section includes the Core Web Vitals report, with speed measured on real users. We explain it in detail in Core Web Vitals: LCP, INP and CLS.
How to combine GA4 and Search Console data
The real value appears when you combine the two tools.
Linking the two tools
You can see Search Console data inside GA4:
- In GA4, go to Admin > Product links > Search Console links.
- Choose your site’s Search Console property.
- Select the web data stream.
- Publish the Search Console reports in GA4’s report library. Without this step, the link exists but the reports don’t show up in the menu.
What you gain:
- Seeing the full journey by landing page: impressions and clicks on Google, then engagement and key events on your website.
- Spotting pages that bring a lot of organic traffic but don’t generate enquiries, so you can improve them.
One clarification: GA4 won’t show you which exact search generated each enquiry. Queries appear with their clicks and impressions, and key events appear by page. You have to read them together.
The full journey
By combining the data, you can find where the result is being lost:
- Search Console: do I appear for the searches I care about?
- GA4, Acquisition: which channels do people come from?
- GA4, Engagement: what do they do on the site?
- GA4, Key events: do they complete the action I’m after?
If the problem is that you don’t appear, the work is SEO. If people arrive but they’re not the right audience, you need to review which searches each page targets. If the right audience arrives and doesn’t get in touch, the problem is the page itself.
What to check every week and every month
You don’t need to look at everything every day. A dashboard with the essentials and a fixed routine are enough.
Every week (15 minutes):
- Active users in GA4, compared with the previous week.
- Engagement rate: whether it dropped noticeably.
- Key events, in total and by channel.
- Clicks and impressions in Search Console.
- New queries in the top 10 positions.
- New indexing errors.
Every month (1 hour):
- The full journey, from search to key event.
- Underperforming pages: many impressions and few clicks, or lots of traffic and few key events.
- Queries between positions 4 and 20, to choose which pages to improve.
- Comparison with the same month last year.
Be careful with recent data: Search Console takes a couple of days to have complete data, so don’t draw conclusions from the last two days.
Common mistakes when measuring your website
1. Watching vanity metrics
Focusing only on total visits or page views, without looking at who arrives or whether they do anything. A thousand visits from the right audience are worth more than ten thousand that will never contact you.
2. Not segmenting traffic
Someone who arrives from Google looking for a service behaves differently from someone who arrives from a social media post. Mixing them into a single number hides what’s happening in each channel.
3. Reading a number without context
A metric on its own says little. A 2% CTR can be good for a generic, competitive search and very low for someone searching for your brand by name. Compare against your own history and by type of search.
4. Not defining goals
If you don’t know what you want to measure, you’ll look at everything and understand nothing. Decide first which actions count as a result and set them up as key events.
5. Forgetting the technical foundation
Improving content is of little use if Google can’t crawl or index the site properly. If you need to review that side, see what technical SEO is.
Data doesn’t improve a website on its own. It helps when every number you look at has a question behind it and a decision after it.
Start with the basics: active users, engagement and key events in GA4; impressions, clicks, CTR and position in Search Console. Once you’ve mastered those, the rest becomes much easier to read. And if the numbers show the problem is the website itself, in web design and marketing we explain how to align the two.
If you’d like help measuring your site properly and turning that data into improvements, take a look at our SEO, GEO & AI service and get in touch.


